Home Care Agency vs Private Caregiver
When your parent needs in-home care, you have two main options: hire through an agency or find someone privately. Here's how to decide which is right for your situation.
Quick Comparison
| Factor | Home Care Agency | Private Caregiver |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly cost | $25-40/hour | $15-25/hour |
| Background checks | Agency handles | You must arrange |
| Backup if caregiver sick | Agency provides replacement | You find coverage |
| Taxes and insurance | Agency handles | You are the employer |
| Liability | Agency carries insurance | Your responsibility |
| Training/supervision | Agency provides | You provide |
| Flexibility | Less (agency policies) | More (direct arrangement) |
| Consistency | May rotate caregivers | Same person always |
Option 1: Home Care Agency
How It Works
You contract with a licensed agency that employs caregivers. The agency handles hiring, training, scheduling, payroll, taxes, and insurance. You pay the agency, and they pay the caregiver.
Pros
- Background checks completed
- Caregivers are trained
- Backup if caregiver is sick
- Agency handles all employment paperwork
- Liability insurance included
- Supervision and quality control
- Easy to change caregivers if needed
- Often can start quickly
Cons
- Higher cost (agency overhead)
- Less control over who comes
- May rotate different caregivers
- Minimum hour requirements common
- Agency policies may be inflexible
- Caregiver paid less than you pay
Families who want convenience and peace of mind. Those who don't want to manage employment details. Situations where reliable backup coverage is essential. People with complex care needs requiring trained caregivers.
Option 2: Private (Independent) Caregiver
How It Works
You hire a caregiver directly. They may be found through personal referrals, online platforms like Care.com, or caregiver registries. You become the employer, responsible for all aspects of the employment relationship.
Pros
- Lower hourly cost
- Caregiver earns more per hour
- Same person every time
- More flexibility in duties
- Direct relationship and communication
- Can negotiate schedule and tasks
- No minimum hour requirements
Cons
- You must verify background
- You are responsible for taxes
- No backup if caregiver is unavailable
- Liability falls on you
- You handle any problems
- Must interview and vet candidates
- Risk of misclassification issues
Families who want the same caregiver every time. Those comfortable managing employment responsibilities. When cost is a significant factor. Situations where a strong personal relationship matters most.
If You Hire Privately: What You Must Do
When you hire a private caregiver directly, you become their employer under IRS and labor law. This comes with legal obligations that many families don't realize until there's a problem.
Required Steps
- Run a background check - Criminal history, reference checks, verify experience
- Verify work authorization - Complete Form I-9
- Get an Employer Identification Number (EIN) - From the IRS
- Withhold and pay payroll taxes - Social Security, Medicare, federal and state
- Pay unemployment insurance - State requirements vary
- Carry workers' compensation insurance - Required in most states
- File quarterly tax forms - Federal and state requirements
- Provide year-end tax forms - W-2 for the caregiver
Simplifying Private Hire Paperwork
Services like HomePay, Care.com HomePay, or GTM Payroll Services can handle payroll and tax obligations for a monthly fee ($50-100/month), reducing your administrative burden while you maintain the cost savings of private hire.
Questions to Ask Home Care Agencies
- Are you licensed by the state?
- What background checks do you perform?
- What training do your caregivers receive?
- What is your caregiver turnover rate?
- Will we have a consistent caregiver or rotate?
- What happens if our caregiver calls in sick?
- What is your minimum hours requirement?
- How do you supervise caregivers?
- What is your process for complaints?
- Are you bonded and insured?
- What are your rates? What is included?
- Do you accept long-term care insurance or VA benefits?
Questions to Ask Private Caregiver Candidates
- What caregiving experience do you have?
- What certifications or training do you have?
- Can you provide references from previous families?
- Are you CPR and first aid certified?
- What is your availability? Can you work weekends?
- Do you have reliable transportation?
- Are you comfortable with (specific care tasks)?
- How would you handle an emergency?
- Are you comfortable with pets?
- What are your hourly rate expectations?
- Can you pass a background check?
- What would cause you to leave a position?
Hybrid Options
Some families use a combination: an agency for weekday shifts (when backup is critical) and a private caregiver for weekends (for continuity and cost savings). Or start with an agency to find someone reliable, then transition to private hire if the relationship works well.
What About Caregiver Registries?
Registries (like Care.com or CareLinx) are a middle ground:
- Help you find and screen candidates
- May offer background check services
- Some handle payroll for a fee
- You still become the employer
- Less expensive than full agency care
Making the Right Choice
Choose an agency if:
- You need care to start quickly
- Reliable backup coverage is essential
- You don't want to manage employment paperwork
- Care needs are complex or medical
- You value the protection of liability insurance
Choose private hire if:
- Cost is a major factor
- Having the same person every day is most important
- You're comfortable being an employer
- You have family backup if the caregiver is unavailable
- Care needs are relatively straightforward
Organize Your Home Care
Our Care Coordination Binder helps you track caregiver schedules, duties, and daily notes.
View Resources